LACP - Aggregation Mode Comparison

Return to Wiki Index

LACP 802.3ad

LACP 802.3ad is the IEEE standard for Link Aggregation. It enables the dynamic creation of a link aggregation group (LAG) where multiple physical links are bundled together to form a logical link. LACP automatically manages the aggregation process, ensuring that the load is balanced across the links in the group.

• Uses a negotiation process to establish aggregated links.
• Compatible with IEEE 802.3ad standard.
• Offers dynamic load balancing and fault tolerance.
• Supports Active and Passive modes for LACP negotiation.
• Enables failover if one of the links in the aggregation fails.

Balance-rr

The `balance-rr` (Round Robin) mode is one of the common bonding methods used in Linux systems. It distributes outbound traffic evenly across all available network interfaces, with a simple round-robin scheduling algorithm.

• Traffic is distributed evenly across all links in a sequential manner.
• Suitable for environments where load distribution is a priority.
• Offers no failover protection if one link goes down.
• Not ideal for environments where packet order is critical, as round-robin distribution can result in packet reordering.

Balance-xor

The `balance-xor` mode uses an XOR (exclusive OR) algorithm to determine how traffic is distributed across the links. It uses a combination of source and destination MAC addresses to determine the link that each packet will be sent over.

• Provides load balancing based on hash calculations from the MAC addresses of source and destination.
• Traffic distribution is deterministic and predictable.
• Offers fault tolerance in the event of link failure.
• However, if a large number of flows are directed to the same link, it can result in an unbalanced traffic distribution.

Balance-tlb

The `balance-tlb` (Transmit Load Balancing) mode is a more advanced load balancing option compared to `balance-rr`. It performs load balancing at the transmit level while providing fault tolerance for receive traffic.

• Traffic is load-balanced in a way that both transmit and receive traffic are distributed across all active links.
• Can failover if one of the links fails.
• Does not require LACP or special switch support.
• A good option for improving outbound performance without requiring advanced configurations.

Balance-alb

The `balance-alb` (Adaptive Load Balancing) mode improves upon the `balance-tlb` mode by adding support for adaptive load balancing. This mode automatically adapts to network traffic patterns and balances the load accordingly.

• Supports both transmit and receive load balancing without the need for LACP.
• Dynamic adjustment of traffic distribution based on the network traffic load.
• Provides fault tolerance with automatic failover.
• Suitable for environments where the network traffic varies dynamically.

Recapitulative Table

Mode	Description	Key Features	Fault Tolerance	Load Balancing Method	MAC Address Usage
LACP 802.3ad	Standard IEEE 802.3ad protocol for LACP	Dynamic link aggregation, compatible with LACP negotiation, failover	Yes	Dynamic, based on LACP negotiation	Yes
balance-rr	Round-robin load balancing	Even distribution of outbound traffic, simple to configure	No	Round-robin, sequential	No
balance-xor	XOR-based load balancing based on MAC addresses	Predictable, deterministic traffic distribution	Yes	XOR of source and destination MAC addresses	Yes
balance-tlb	Transmit Load Balancing with receive fault tolerance	Simple, no need for LACP, provides fault tolerance	Yes	Based on traffic volume	No
balance-alb	Adaptive Load Balancing with transmit and receive balancing	Adaptive traffic distribution based on traffic load, fault tolerance	Yes	Dynamic adjustment based on traffic load	No

Useful Links

• [IEEE 802.3ad Standard](https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1384027) - Official document detailing the 802.3ad standard.
• [Linux bonding driver documentation](https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/networking/bonding.txt) - Detailed explanation of the bonding driver and modes in Linux.
• [Link Aggregation Control Protocol (LACP) Overview](https://www.cio.com/article/28673/networking-understanding-lacp-and-its-benefits.html) - Overview of LACP technology and its benefits.
• [Network Bonding Modes in Linux](https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Bonding) - Arch Wiki article on various bonding modes in Linux.
• [Linux Network Bonding Howto](https://www.tldp.org/HOWTO/Bonding-Driver-HOWTO.html) - Comprehensive guide on using the Linux bonding driver.